Drew Barrymore
Role: Beverly Donofrio
Steve Zahn
Role: Ray Hasek
Brittany Murphy
Role: Fay Forrester
James Woods
Role: Leonard Donofrio
Lorraine Bracco
Role: Teresa Donofrio
Rosie Perez
Role: Shirley Perro
Sara Gilbert
Role: Tina Barr
Peter Facinelli
Role: Tommy Butcher
Mika Boorem
Role: Beverly Donofrio (Age 11)
Vincent Pastore
Role: Uncle Lou
Maryann Urbano
Role: Aunt Ann
Alexia Landeau
Role: Jenny
Kristin Proctor
Role: Cindy
Celine Ordioni
Role: Janet Donofrio (Age 8)
Alissa Dean
Role: Townie Girl #1
Jessica Leshnower
Role: Townie Girl #2
Lauren Lake
Role: Karen's Friend
Desmond Harrington
Role: Bobby
Gabriel Carpenter
Role: Sky Barrister
Vincent De Paul
Role: Linebacker
Joseph Cassese
Role: Linebacker
Kevin O'Rourke
Role: Jail Ward
Susan Forristal
Role: Mrs. Forrester
John Bedford Lloyd
Role: Mr. Forrester
Paz de la Huerta
Role: Phone Call Flirt
Olivia Morgan Scheck
Role: Janet Donofrio (Age 12)
Dusty Rizzo
Role: Wedding Singer Tony
Carl Capotorto
Role: Cop #1
Robert Greenhut
Role: Cop #2
Heather Hodder
Role: Donofrio Cousin
Joseph M. Cannizaro
Role: Jason (Newborn)
Noah Hartwick
Role: Jason (Newborn)
Briana Tilden
Role: Jason (Baby)
Skye Arens
Role: Jason (Age 1)
Patrick Salerno
Role: Jason (Age 2)
Robert Salerno
Role: Jason (Age 2)
Logan Arens
Role: Jason (Age 3)
Samantha Reale
Role: Amelia (Age 3)
Jon Korkes
Role: Counselor
Cody Arens
Role: Jason (Age 6)
Samantha Lucier
Role: Amelia (Age 6)
Gaetano Lisi
Role: Sweeny's Owner
Marisa Ryan
Role: Janet Donofrio (Age 19)
Maggie Gyllenhaal
Role: Amelia
Logan Lerman
Role: Jason (Age 8)
Skye McCole Bartusiak
Role: Amelia (Age 8)
Michael Linstroth
Role: Dennis Forrester
Sophia Barricelli
Role: Sophia (uncredited)
Shani Bayne Haller
Role: Waitress (uncredited)
J.D. Brookshire
Role: Jerk in Car (uncredited)
Toni D'Antonio
Role: Tied-Dyed Girl (uncredited)
Anna Damergis
Role: Cop's Wife (uncredited)
Gene Gabriel
Role: Make-Out Guy (uncredited)
Jaime Gallagher
Role: Car Passenger (uncredited)
Donna Sue Jahier
Role: Woman in Maternity Ward (uncredited)
Rich Keen
Role: Passer By in Car (uncredited)
Richard Keith
Role: Heald Family Member (uncredited)
Sara Klingebiel
Role: Townie Girl #3 (uncredited)
Randi Rosenholtz
Role: Townie Girl #4 (uncredited)
Peter Austin Noto
Role: Short Order Cook (uncredited)
Dana Segal
Role: Hippie Neighbor (uncredited)
Mario Simone
Role: Student (uncredited)
Marilyn Spanier
Role: Mary (uncredited)
Todd Wall
Role: Nice Guy at Party (uncredited)
Bill Walters
Role: Hippie at Party (uncredited)
