Fredric March
Role: Jonathan / Nathaniel / Samuel / Wallace Wooley
Veronica Lake
Role: Jennifer
Robert Benchley
Role: Dr. Dudley White
Susan Hayward
Role: Estelle Masterson
Cecil Kellaway
Role: Daniel
Elizabeth Patterson
Role: Margaret
Robert Warwick
Role: J. B. Masterson
Georgia Backus
Role: Older Woman (uncredited)
Charles Bates
Role: Wooley's Son (uncredited)
Brooks Benedict
Role: Country Club Guest (uncredited)
Billy Bevan
Role: Puritan Vendor (uncredited)
Edward Biby
Role: Spectator at Fire (uncredited)
Marie Blake
Role: Purity Sykes (uncredited)
Monte Blue
Role: Doorman (uncredited)
Aldrich Bowker
Role: Justice of the Peace (uncredited)
Al Bridge
Role: Second Prison Guard (uncredited)
Nora Cecil
Role: Harriet Wooley (uncredited)
Ann Carter
Role: Jennifer Wooley (uncredited)
Chester Conklin
Role: Party Bartender (uncredited)
Gordon De Main
Role: Man with Masterson on Radio (uncredited)
Emma Dunn
Role: Wife of Justice of the Peace (uncredited)
Ralph Dunn
Role: First Prison Guard (uncredited)
Mary Field
Role: Nancy Wooley (uncredited)
Bess Flowers
Role: Matron of Honor (uncredited)
Joe Gilbert
Role: Wedding Guest (uncredited)
Florence Gill
Role: Woman Playing Chess (uncredited)
Robert Greig
Role: Town Crier (uncredited)
Eily Malyon
Role: Tabitha Wooley (uncredited)
Charles R. Moore
Role: Rufus - Samuel's Servant (uncredited)
Viola Moore
Role: Martha (uncredited)
Emory Parnell
Role: Allen - Hotel Owner (uncredited)
Helen St. Rayner
Role: Singer at Wedding (uncredited)
Oscar 'Dutch' Hendrian
Role:
Esther Howard
Role: Extra (uncredited)