Lily Collins
Role: Liz Kendall
Kaya Scodelario
Role: Carole Anne Boone
Jeffrey Donovan
Role: Utah Defense Attorney John O'Connell
Angela Sarafyan
Role: Joanna
Dylan Baker
Role: Utah Prosecutor David Yocom
Brian Geraghty
Role: Florida Public Defender Dan Dowd
Terry Kinney
Role: Detective Mike Fisher
Haley Joel Osment
Role: Liz's Co-Worker Jerry
James Hetfield
Role: Officer Bob Hayward
Grace Victoria Cox
Role: Carol Daronch
Jim Parsons
Role: Florida Prosecutor Larry Simpson
John Malkovich
Role: Judge Edward D. Cowart
Sydney Vollmer
Role: Babysitter
Macie Carmosino
Role: 2 Yr Old Molly
Ava Inman
Role: 4 Yr Old Molly
Morgan Pyle
Role: 8 Yr Old Molly
Richard K. Jones
Role: Interrogation Room Sheriff
Justin Inman
Role: Police Lineup Suspect
Alan B. Jones
Role: Utah Judge Stewart Hanson
Maya Berlinger
Role: Concerned Library Co-Ed
Derek Snow
Role: Security Guard
Leilani Barrett
Role: Liz's Boss
Ryan Wesley Gilreath
Role: Deputy Westerlund
Ken Strunk
Role: Colorado Judge George Lohr
Jared Joplin
Role: Colorado District Attorney Frank Tucker
Justin McCombs
Role: Colorado Defense Attorney Jim Dumas
Joe Berlinger
Role: Colorado Jailhouse Reporter
Brandon Trost
Role: Colorado Jailhouse Cameraman
Tim Young
Role: Colorado Jailhouse Boom Op
Torrie Wiggins
Role: Woman w/Dog
Chris Petty
Role: Officer David Lee
Kevin McClatchy
Role: Sherriff Ken Katsaris
Paul Kulis
Role: Visitation Room Guard
Michael Simkin
Role: Florida Reporter
Tess Talbot
Role: Florida Public Defender Margaret Good
David Myers Gregory
Role: Bailiff Dave Watson
Ming Wang
Role: Court Clerk Shirley Lewis
Sarah Berlinger
Role: Bundy Groupie #1
Claire Sinofsky
Role: Bundy Groupie #2
Caroline Hurwitz
Role: Bundy Groupie #3
Savannah Rodin
Role: Enchanted Girl
James Harper
Role: Detective Chapman
Forba Shepherd
Role: Louise Bundy
Barry Mulholland
Role: Dr. Richard Souviron
Joey Boyd
Role: Bribable Guard
Ally Sereda
Role: Liz's Secretary
Grace Balbo
Role: Teenage Molly
Amy Greene
Role: Ted Bundy Victim
Chris Hahn
Role: Utah Courthouse Bailiff
Rajiim A. Gross
Role: Metro Justice Journalist (uncredited)
Calvin David Jones III
Role: Utah Prisoner (uncredited)
James Siderits
Role: Prisoner's Attorney (uncredited)
Bret Aaron Knower
Role: Utah State Prison Guard (uncredited)
John E. Brownlee
Role: Miami Prison Guard (uncredited)
Jerry Mullins
Role: Utah State Prisoner (uncredited)
