Abby Ryder Fortson
Role: Margaret Simon
Rachel McAdams
Role: Barbara Simon
Kathy Bates
Role: Sylvia Simon
Elle Graham
Role: Nancy Wheeler
Benny Safdie
Role: Herbert Simon
Amari Alexis Price
Role: Janie Loomis
Katherine Mallen Kupferer
Role: Gretchen Potter
Kate MacCluggage
Role: Mrs. Jan Wheeler
Aidan Wojtak-Hissong
Role: Moose Freed
Landon S. Baxter
Role: Evan Wheeler
Echo Kellum
Role: Mr. Benedict
Mia Dillon
Role: Mary Hutchins
Gary Houston
Role: Paul Hutchins
Mackenzie Joy Potter
Role: Mamma Bunny
Olivia Williams
Role: Witch
Mike Platarote Jr.
Role: Guy in Car
Simms May
Role: Norman Fisher
Zack Brooks
Role: Philip Leroy
JeCobi Swain
Role: Freddy Barnett
Wilbur Fitzgerald
Role: Morris Binamin
Ethan McDowell
Role: Mr. Wheeler
Sloane Warren
Role: Mrs. Fisher
Isol Young
Role: Laura Danker
Naida Nelson
Role: PTA Mother
Tahirah Harrison
Role: PTA Mother
Zach Humphrey
Role: Salvation Army Guy
Karen Aruj
Role: Department Store Sales Lady
Judy Blume
Role: Neighbor Walking Dog #1
George Cooper
Role: Neighbor Walking Dog #2
Joan Jackson
Role: Neighbor
Stephen Jackson
Role: Neighbor
Robert Haulbrook
Role: Rough Looking Guy on Bus
Johnny Land
Role: The General
Jennifer Errington
Role: New York Restaurant Waitress
Evan Bergman
Role: Greg the Greeter
Michael Wolk
Role: Rabbi Kellerman
Karen Macarah
Role: Cantor
Ariel DiDonato
Role: Aliyah
Claude Deuce
Role: Gospel Singer / Pastor
Keya Hamilton
Role: Gospel Singer
Tanya J. McClellan
Role: Mrs. Loomis
Dennis Delamar
Role: Mailman
Samantha LeBrocq
Role: Mrs. Potter
Wally White
Role: Protestant Minister
Holli Saperstein
Role: Mrs. Webster
Deborah Helms
Role: Sweet Old Lady Cashier
Cooper Herrett
Role: 17 Year Old Cashier
Gezell Fleming
Role: School Librarian
Jim France
Role: Catholic Priest
Rakeem Massingill
Role: Art Student
Mary Clare Mitchell
Role: Pedestrian
