Brooke Bradshaw
Role: Veronica (New Years)
Wesley Alley
Role: Uncle Bob (Christmas)
Whitney Alley
Role: Party Guest (Christmas)
Michael Antosy
Role: Eran Lawrence (Easter)
Amy Baklini
Role: Doctor's Voicemail (voice)
Ronan Barbour
Role: Doyle (St. Patrick's Day)
Adam Beigel
Role: Kris Anderson (Christmas)
Michelle Bernard
Role: Judy (Chanukah)
Darren Lynn Bousman
Role: Orignial Killer Santa (Christmas)
Alexandra Boylan
Role: Josi (Thanksgiving)
Arielle Brachfeld
Role: Girl in Woods (Halloween)
Hannah Carleton
Role: Home Buyer (Halloween)
Brian C. Chenworth
Role: New Killer Santa Clause (Christmas)
Micah Cohen
Role: Party Goer (New Years)
Brandon Conner
Role: Jeffery (Halloween)
Ivet Corvea
Role: Gloria (4th of July)
Francis Cronin
Role: Sheamus G (St. Patrick's Day)
Taylor Cross
Role: Dan (New Years)
Lenora Elisabeth
Role: Ciara (St. Patrick's Day)
Michael J. Epstein
Role: Mr. Keane (St. Patrick's Day)
Bradley Fowler
Role: Party Guest (Christmas)
Charlie Frohne
Role: Radio News Reporter (Easter) (voice)
John K.D. Graham
Role: Monster (Thanksgiving)
Josh Hammond
Role: Jesse (4th of July)
Alethea Hnatko-Cho
Role: Clara (St. Patrick's Day)
Christopher M. Jimenez
Role: Party Guest (Christmas)
Breeanna Judy
Role: Party Guest (Christmas)
Darius Karsas
Role: Father Time (New Years)
Neil King
Role: Party Guest (Christmas)
Erica Lamkin
Role: Laura (Labor Day)
Matt Larson
Role: Allen (New Years)
Lisa Mason Lee
Role: Diane (New Years)
Bobbi Sue Luther
Role: Party Guest (Christmas)
Rene Michelle Aranda
Role: Party Goer (New Years)
Micah Cohler
Role: Party Guest (New Years / Father Time)
Raiven Lynn
Role: Shawna (Christmas / Merry and Fright)
Andrew Maiorano
Role: Raven Entity (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)
Hercules Magnus
Role: Hercules (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)
Amanda Markowitz
Role: Tara / Party Game Player 2 (New Years / Father Time)
Kevin Marron
Role: Mr. G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)
Victoria Matlock
Role: Jessica / Party Game Player 1 (New Years / Father Time)
Marty McFly
Role: Marty (Easter / Forty Winks)
Brian McGrath
Role: Strange Walker (Easter / Forty Winks)
Matt McWilliams
Role: Home Buyer (Halloween / Candy)
Nell Nakkan
Role: Mrs. Keane (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)
Maitlyn Pezzo
Role: Holly (Christmas / Merry and Fright)
Jodie Panek
Role: Mom (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)
Demetrius Phillips
Role: Kevin (4th of July / 4th of July)
Nicolas Quijano
Role: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)
Rachel Rath
Role: Mrs. G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)
Patrick Joseph Rieger
Role: Mike (Halloween / Candy)
Benton Robertson
Role: Patrick G (St. Patrick's Day / Becoming Patrick)
Charlotte Rothwell
Role: TV News Reporter (Easter / Forty Winks) (voice)
Angelica Salek
Role: Beth Anderson (Christmas / Merry and Fright)
Brian Sapir
Role: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)
Curtis Schultz
Role: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)
Daniel Schweiger
Role: Soloman (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)
Steven Shea
Role: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Bright)
Catherine Siggins
Role: Aunty Lorna McGlory (St. Patrick's / Becoming Patrick)
Dan Snowden
Role: Real Estate Man (Halloween / Candy)
Jessica Sonneborn
Role: Jane / Betty (4th of July / 4th of July, Labor Day / Labor Day)
Michael Varrati
Role: Party Guest (Christmas / Merry and Fright)
Jennifer Vincent
Role: Crystal (Hanukkah / Hanukkah)
Jeff Wiesen
Role: Cop / James (4th of July / 4th of July, Labor Day / Labor Day)
Wes Sneeringer
Role: 911 Operator (uncredited)
Khaled Zakher
Role: Store Clerk (Thanksgiving / Cranberry Sauce)
Lauren Chavez-Myers
Role: Lilith Hicks (Easter)
DaNae Martinez
Role: Charlotte Anderson (Christmas / Merry and Fright)