Robert De Niro
Role: Paul Vitti
Billy Crystal
Role: Dr. Ben Sobel
Lisa Kudrow
Role: Laura MacNamara Sobel
Chazz Palminteri
Role: Primo Sidone
Kresh Novakovic
Role: '50s Gangster
Bart Tangredi
Role: Young Vitti, Sr.
Michael Straka
Role: Young Dominic Manetta
Joseph Rigano
Role: Dominic Manetta
Richard C. Castellano
Role: Jimmy Boots
Molly Shannon
Role: Caroline
Max Casella
Role: Nicky Shivers
Frank Pietrangolare
Role: Tuna
Kyle Sabihy
Role: Michael Sobel
Bill Macy
Role: Dr. Isaac Sobel
Rebecca Schull
Role: Dorothy Sobel
Pat Cooper
Role: Salvatore Masiello
Leo Rossi
Role: Carlo Mangano
Aasif Mandvi
Role: Dr. Shulman
Michael Haley
Role: Producer
Ian Marioles
Role: Soundman
DonnaMarie Recco
Role: Sheila
Jimmie Ray Weeks
Role: FBI Agent Steadman
Bob Cea
Role: FBI Agent Ricci
William Hill
Role: FBI Agent Provano
Ira Wheeler
Role: Scott MacNamara
Luce Ennis
Role: Belinda MacNamara
Elizabeth Bracco
Role: Marie Vitti
Gina Gallagher
Role: Theresa Vitti
Francesca Mari
Role: Anna Vitti
Vinny Vella, Jr.
Role: Anthony Vitti
Mickey Bruno
Role: Miami Soldier
Dave Corey
Role: Miami Hall Guard
Fred Workman
Role: Justice of the Peace
Daniel W. Barringer
Role: Dream Sequence Gunman
John Polce
Role: Dream Sequence Gunman
Drew Eliot
Role: Priest at Funeral
Grace DeSena
Role: Tommy Angels' Widow
New York Joe Catalfumo
Role: Exuberant Mourner
Michael Guarino, Jr.
Role: Stevie Beef
Michael Harkins
Role: Paretti's Family
Paula Raflo
Role: Paretti's Family
Ondine Harris
Role: Paretti's Family
Matthew Vega
Role: Paretti's Family
Clem Caserta
Role: Handsome Jack
Tony Ray Rossi
Role: Potatoes
Judith Kahan
Role: Elaine Felton
Pasquale Cajano
Role: Joe Baldassare
Gene Ruffini
Role: Frankie Zello
Alfred Sauchelli, Jr.
Role: Mo-Mo
Tony DiBenedetto
Role: Johnny "Bigs"
Frank Aquilino
Role: Eddie "Cokes"
Tony Bennett
Role: Tony Bennett
Joseph Bonanno
Role: Joseph Bonanno (archive footage)
Joe Gallo
Role: Joe Gallo (archive footage)
Kenny Alfonso
Role: Car Chase Driver (uncredited)
Phillip V. Caruso
Role: Wedding Photographer (uncredited)
Anthony Caso
Role: Johnny Angel (uncredited)
Richard D'Alessandro
Role: Gangster (uncredited)
Trish Dempsey
Role: Hotel Guest (uncredited)
Tony Devon
Role: Bobby Angel (uncredited)
Benim Foster
Role: SWAT Team Leader (uncredited)
Russell Gibson
Role: Mafio Capo (uncredited)
Joseph Hardin
Role: Man in Commercial (uncredited)
James Morricone
Role: Wise Guy (uncredited)
Michael Rothberger
Role: Soldier (uncredited)
Paul Scannapieco
Role: Freddie the Fruitman (uncredited)
Vinny Vella
Role: Mobster at Meeting (uncredited)